A most welcome, though not definitive, addition to the study of this riddle is the recent examination of these two classical figures in socrates and aristophanes by leo strauss, who is robert m hutchins distinguished service professor of political science. Hu, ying x dr joanne grasso icph-302-f02-fa14 september 13, 2014 unit 2- aristophanes and xenophon there are two categories of information about socrates, the primary source, which are the writings, and the secondary sources are the comedies. Xenophon (greek: ξενοφῶν, xenophōn c 430 - 354 bc), son of gryllus, of the deme erchia of athens, also known as xenophon of athens, was a greek historian, soldier, mercenary, philosopher and a contemporary and admirer of socrates. Socrates is one of the principal characters of aristophanes' comedy, clouds and xenophon, a historian and military leader, wrote, like plato, both an apology of socrates (an account of socrates' trial) and other works in which socrates appears as a principal speaker furthermore, we have some fragmentary remains of dialogues written by other. In the discussion that follows no attempt is made to link xenophon's views on sparta to specific aspects of his biography xenophon's long-running involvement with sparta was an undeniably important part of his life, and that involvement made him an unusually well-informed observer of spartan life.
C he among you is find someone to write my paper the wisest who, like socrates, knows that his wisdom is really worth nothing at all concise article on a discussion of the works by xenophon and aristophanes the historical context of a discussion of the works by xenophon and aristophanes this movement. Aristophanes essay examples 46 total results a literary analysis of aristophanes views on love a discussion of the works by xenophon and aristophanes 713 words. Xenophon, aristophanes, and aristotle were all his students or had learned from him, more importantly his thoughts his thoughts were fairly complex, and ahead of his time, however, he had been able to question every. 15 - socrates without plato: the accounts of aristophanes 15 - socrates without plato: the accounts of aristophanes and xenophon posted on 23 january 2011 in the first of several episodes on socrates, peter discusses his portrayals in the clouds of aristophanes and in the works of the historian xenophon.
Xenophon's other famous work, memorabilia, deals in part with his memories of socrates, and in the passage below, he addresses socrates' trial and execution by the athenians in 399 bce the work is important in that, aside from plato's famous apology , it is the only written account dealing with the trial of socrates extant. Start studying philosophers: plato's symposium learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Xenophon is surely conscious of this fact when presenting ischomachos' discussion of the queen bee 46 in fact, the wife herself comments that ischomachos would be more suitable for the role of leader of the bees (739) and xenophon himself equates the persian king with the king bee of a hive in another text (cyr 5124. The greek philosophers study • greek - arabic - latin works by xenophon, aristotle, and aristophanes also provide important insights. According to dorion, so far from representing the language, or even the thought, of prodicus, the choice of heracles is in every respect the work of xenophon alone, and represents 'in fact a sort of epitome of the major ethical positions upheld by socrates and by xenophon'14 of course, if z philip ambrose is right to see the influence of.
Xenophon's conversations of socrates is a great addition to the home library of any lover of socratic philosophy xenophon's work can easily be described as four books within a book his four topics include socrates' defense, memoirs of socrates, the dinner-party, and estate manager. The trials of socrates: six classic texts by plato, aristophanes, xenophon lampooned in 406 bce in a blistering aristophanic satire, socrates was tried in 399 bce on a charge of corrupting the youth, convicted by a jury of about five hundred of his peers, and condemned to death. We do not have any writings of socrates himself preserved instead, we have reports about socrates in the works of plato, xenophon, aristophanes, and later writers. Xenophon's symposium is a depiction of socrates in conversation with his friends at a drinking party (it is perhaps inspired by a work of plato of the same name and character) and is regarded by some scholars as a valuable re-creation of socrates' thought and way of life.
- aristophanes clouds reflects general public opinion at the time, whether this is close to the truth or not - treated in platos apology as the typical expression of popular prejudice - stresses the secret, elitist and anti social character of socrates' teachings. Homer, and socrates in xenophon, aristophanes' clouds, plato's greater hippias and phaedrus in the first book of the iliad agamemnon, the supreme commander of the greek forces, dishonoured achilles, the greatest greek hero. Life early years xenophon was born around 430 bc, near the city of athens, to gryllus, of the deme erchia of athenshis father's family were a wealthy equestrian family.
Study guide for the clouds the clouds study guide contains a biography of aristophanes, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. For example, the philosopher xenophon of athens was a student and admirer of socrates, who dedicated himself to the preservation of socrates's wisdom specifically, in the anabasis , xenophon writes of asking socrates for advice regarding his entrance into the service of cyrus when he was a young man. Select an author from the list below to see a list of works by that author then, select one of the titles to view the work or follow the read discussion link to participate in a discussion about the work.
Provides a brief, but very clear, overview of socrates' life and death, the socratic problem, and the contrasting portraits of socrates in aristophanes, plato, xenophon, and aristotle guthrie, w k c 1971. In plato's later works socrates speaks with what seem to be largely plato's ideas, but in the earlier dialogues—considered by historians to be the most accurate portrayal—socrates rarely. A discussion of their respective circumstances (1a-2b) leads to the discussion of holiness that engages them for the rest of the dialogue two dialogues also are set after the apology , and so implicitly offer a commentary on the trial. Xenophon: xenophon, greek historian and philosopher whose numerous surviving works are valuable for their depiction of late classical greece his anabasis (upcountry march) in particular was highly regarded in antiquity and had a strong influence on latin literature.